Planetary imaging · Step 2 of 7
Aperture and focal length: which one sets the detail and which the size
In a sentence: Diameter decides how much detail is there; focal length and pixel size, how many pixels you see it in. Both, and in that order.
Aperture first: it sets the ceiling
Before talking about focal length you have to talk about diameter, because that’s what decides the smallest detail your telescope can separate. That limit doesn’t depend on the camera or on the Barlow: light diffracts coming through a round opening, so a star never quite becomes a point, and the narrower the opening, the more it spreads. The working rule is the Dawes limit, which isn’t theoretical but measured on double stars: 116 divided by the diameter in millimeters, and the answer is in arcseconds.
| Aperture | Smallest detail | Light gathered |
|---|---|---|
| 100 mm | 1.16″ | ×1 |
| 127 mm | 0.91″ | ×1.6 |
| 150 mm | 0.77″ | ×2.3 |
| 200 mm | 0.58″ | ×4 |
| 250 mm | 0.46″ | ×6.3 |
| 300 mm | 0.39″ | ×9 |
Light gathered goes with the square of the diameter, taking the 100 mm as the reference. These are theoretical figures, with perfect optics and still air: on a normal night the seeing rules, which is why a well collimated, cooled-down telescope outperforms a bigger one that isn’t.
The same size isn’t the same detail
Pau Montplet (AstroBreda), who shoots planets with a C11 and has two NASA Astronomy Pictures of the Day (APODs), pointed this out to us after reading the guide: at the same focal length, the same camera and the same seeing, a 250/1500 pulls out more detail than a 127/1500. Both have the same focal length, so they give the same arcseconds per pixel and the planet comes out the same size in the image. But one’s ceiling is 0.46″ and the other’s is 0.91″: on the 250 there’s real detail where on the 127 there’s only a bigger blur. (Those are each tube’s ceiling; actually collecting all of it also takes the focal length your camera asks for, and that comes next.)
And it gathers nearly four times the light, so it can expose shorter, record more frames per second and keep more of the moments when the air was still.
Focal length on its own adds no detail: it spreads it over more pixels, so what the telescope already resolves doesn’t end up inside a single one. That’s why the order is this: first the aperture you can afford, mount and move; then the focal length your camera asks for.
Slide the focal length
Pick a planet, pick your camera and move the focal length: on the left you’ll see the whole sensor (and how small the planet is on it) and on the right the actual pixels it covers. Look at the marks: a 300 mm telephoto, a 600–800 mm refractor and a 2,000 mm Schmidt-Cassegrain, with and without a Barlow.
- Image scale
- Size on the sensor
- Each video, at most
Photos: Jupiter, Raúl Hussein · Saturn and Mars, NASA, ESA, STScI, A. Simon, M. Wong and J. Bell (Hubble), CC BY 4.0 · the Moon, Fran López. Jupiter’s moons are drawn.
The focal ratio rule
The ideal focal length depends on your camera: to pull out all the detail the telescope allows, the focal ratio (focal length ÷ aperture) should be about 5 times the pixel size in microns. With a 2.9 µm pixel, around f/15; with 3.76 µm, f/19. More doesn’t give more detail: just a bigger, darker, noisier image.
| Telescope | Focal ratio | Barlow | Final focal length |
|---|---|---|---|
| Newtonian 150/750 | f/5 | 3× | 2,250 mm (f/15) |
| Newtonian 200/1000 | f/5 | 3× | 3,000 mm (f/15) |
| Maksutov 127/1500 | f/12 | None, or 1.5× | 1,500–2,250 mm |
| Schmidt-Cassegrain 235/2350 (a C9.25) | f/10 | 1.5× or 2× | 3,500–4,700 mm |
If the night’s turbulence is middling, it’s better to stay a little short (f/10–f/12): less magnification, a brighter and steadier image.