What calibration frames do I need?
Darks, flats, dark flats, bias… how many, and do you have to redo them every night? It depends on your camera and on what you've touched. Two clicks and you'll know.
Your night
Flats
Dark flats
Bias
Why temperature matters
Your sensor makes signal even with no light reaching it, just from being warm: that's dark current, and it roughly doubles every 6 °C. That signal is exactly what a dark frame removes; what you can't remove is the noise it leaves behind, and that grows more slowly. Drag the temperature and watch a 5-minute dark fill up.
A cooled camera sits at −10 °C all night; a DSLR on a warm summer night can run past 30 °C. That's why its darks never quite match: the temperature keeps moving while you shoot.
Heads-up, DSLR shooters: the camera heats itself up. They start out at air temperature, but the electronics and the long exposures push the sensor up 4 to 6 °C over a run, and the noise with it.
Go for slightly shorter subs with a gap between them, which you can set on your intervalometer: 60 s on, 15 s off, say. And put the camera outside half an hour before you start, so it settles at the outdoor temperature: if it's 25 °C indoors and 15 °C out, your first subs won't match anything.
The trick: darks on a cloudy night. Wait for a cloudy night at about the temperature of your session and run the same sequence with the cap on (and the viewfinder covered): same exposure, same ISO, same gaps. The sensor climbs the same way (18 to 24 °C, for instance) and the darks match almost sub for sub. You don't burn a clear night, and you build a library by temperature.
Canon bodies record the camera temperature in every frame. To stack, in ASTAP (free) check Classify by › Dark temperature on the stack tab and set the tolerance, ±3 °C for instance. ASTAP then matches each light to the darks shot at its temperature. No sorting by hand. See the ASTAP documentation.
A bit of backstory. That checkbox exists because of one summer night. When I was starting out I shot with a Canon EOS R in Seville, where summer nights hover around 30 °C, and my darks never matched my lights. I pitched the idea to Han Kleijn, the author of ASTAP. He liked it and added it. Thanks, Han.
The cheat sheet
-
Darks
20 to 50
- Redo them
- When the exposure, the gain or the offset changes (the ISO, on a DSLR), or the sensor temperature does.
- They depend on
- The camera, not the scope.
-
Flats
20 to 30 per filter
- Redo them
- When you rotate the camera, refocus, swap filters or pick up new dust.
- They depend on
- The whole optical train.
-
Dark flats
As many as your flats
- Redo them
- When the flat exposure changes.
- They depend on
- The camera.
-
Bias
30 to 50
- Redo them
- Almost never: they keep for months.
- They depend on
- The camera. Mostly useful on a DSLR.
More calibration frames mean less noise in the final image, but past 50 you barely notice. Your Bortle class and your target change nothing: calibration is about your camera and your optics, not about the sky.
Quick answers
- How many dark frames do I need?
- 20 to 50. Redo them when the exposure, the gain or the offset changes (the ISO, on a DSLR), or when the sensor temperature does. With a cooled camera at a fixed setpoint, a library keeps for months.
- Do I need to take flats every night?
- Flats depend on the whole optical train, so you need new ones whenever you rotate the camera, refocus, swap filters or pick up new dust. If nothing moved, your last set will do — but shooting them every session is the safe bet.
- Do I need both bias frames and dark flats?
- With a dedicated CMOS camera, no: dark flats are more reliable than bias. On a DSLR it's the other way around: the bias frames do that job, and they keep for months.
Shooting from a tripod instead? The exposure calculator gives you the seconds per sub, and the field of view calculator shows how your gear frames the target. The full guide to calibration is in Spanish for now: Calibración: darks, flats, bias y dark flats.