Capture
Calibration: darks, flats, bias and dark flats
In a sentence: They are separate photos that clean up the good ones: darks take out the camera’s noise, flats the dust and the dark corners, and bias or dark flats set the flats right.
The essentials
Darks are taken capped, at the same exposure, gain and temperature as the lights; with a cooled camera they’re good for many nights (a library). Flats are taken with an even light in front, without touching focus, rotation or filter: one set per filter, and again whenever something changes. Bias are frames at the shortest exposure; with CMOS cameras many people prefer dark flats (darks at the exposure of the flats). With several exposure sets (HDR), darks for each one.
What each one is for
Darks: frames with the telescope capped, at the same exposure, gain and temperature as the good ones; they record the thermal noise and the hot pixels so they can be subtracted. Flats: frames of an evenly lit surface; they record the vignetting and the dust motes so they can be corrected. Bias or dark flats: the dark frames that go with the flats.
When to take them again
With a cooled camera, darks are kept and are good for many nights at the same exposure, gain and temperature. Flats, on the other hand, depend on the dust, the focus and the rotation of the camera: the safe thing is to take them every night, without touching anything in the optical train.
Temperature changes everything
The sensor generates signal even with no light reaching it, just from being warm: that’s the dark current, and it roughly doubles every 6 °C (11 °F). A dark at 20 °C (68 °F) carries about ten times more thermal noise than one at 0 °C (32 °F).
That’s why a cooled camera, always at the same temperature (−10 °C, or 14 °F, say), can use the same dark library for months. A DSLR or an uncooled camera warms up and cools down through the night: its darks fit worse, and with them dithering matters more, because it scatters the hot pixels so the stack can remove them.
How many? It depends which
Darks: 20 to 50. They have to match in exposure, gain, offset and temperature; change any of the four and you need new ones. They don’t depend on the telescope or on the filter.
Flats: 20 to 30 per filter. They depend on the whole optical train: the filter, the focus, the rotation of the camera and the dust. Touch anything and you take them again.
Dark flats: as many as the flats, at the same exposure as the flats. Bias: 30 to 50 at the shortest exposure the camera allows; in DSLRs they work well and last for months, but in many dedicated CMOS cameras they’re less reliable and dark flats are the better bet.
More frames put less noise into the final photo, but above 50 you hardly notice. Neither the Bortle class nor the object changes anything: calibration frames belong to the camera and the telescope, not to the sky.
Darks with a DSLR: the cloudy-night library
A DSLR has no cooling, but its temperature isn’t random: it depends on the temperature outside and on how the camera warms up over a run of frames. Repeat both and the sensor follows the same path. That’s why it works to shoot your darks on another night, a cloudy one, with a similar outside temperature and the same sequence: the same exposure, the same ISO and the same pauses between shots. If on the good night the sensor went from 18 to 24 °C (64 to 75 °F), on the cloudy one it will do almost the same.
Before you start, on both nights, put the camera outside for half an hour so it comes down to the outside temperature. Cap the lens, and the viewfinder too, since light gets in there on long exposures. Canon bodies record the temperature in every photo, so you can build up darks by temperature (at 5, 10 and 15 °C, or 41, 50 and 59 °F…). And for stacking, ASTAP, which is free, matches each light with the darks at its temperature on its own: in the stacking tab, “Classify by › Dark temperature”, with whatever margin you choose (±3 °C, about 5 °F, say). Renew the library once a year: new hot pixels show up over time.
An example: one night with a cooled camera
With a camera cooled to −10 °C (14 °F), 300 s frames at gain 100 and three filters (L, R and G): the 300 s darks at gain 100 and −10 °C come straight out of the library, with nothing to do. When you finish, without touching the focus or the rotation, 25 flats per filter (75 in all) and as many dark flats with the cap on. About ten minutes.
And in your case? Tell us your camera and what you changed, and we’ll say what to redo tonight.
Which calibration frames?