Skip to content
ES App (ES) ↗
Step 3 of 8: Black or green?

Processing: the essentials · Step 3 of 8

“Eight hours and I can’t see a thing!”: why it comes out black, or green

In a sentence: The freshly stacked image looks black, or green if the software brightens it for you. Nothing is wrong: it just isn’t stretched yet. It takes a moment to fix.

The first thing you’ll see

You’ve spent eight hours on the Orion Nebula, you stack, you open the result… and the screen is black, with four stars on it. Or, if the program brightens it automatically, everything is green. That’s the blank-face moment every one of us has had. Relax: the nebula is in there. These are real frames of the Wizard Nebula, freshly stacked:

The Wizard Nebula freshly stacked and unstretched: an almost black field with a few stars; the nebula is nowhere to be seen.

Freshly stacked: “where’s the nebula?”

The same image with the automatic stretch: thousands of stars on an intense green background and, in the middle, the Wizard Nebula in green.

With the autostretch: there it is! (and green)

The Wizard Nebula (NGC 7380), photos by Fran López. Both are the same stacked image: all that changes is how it’s displayed.

Linear: the light exactly as it arrived

The stacked image is linear: if a star sent a hundred times more light than the nebula, the image holds a value a hundred times larger. The trouble is that the faint nebula and the background take up barely the first 1% of the values, and the screen, which is linear too, paints them almost black. The stars, on the other hand, do show.

Stretching means making it non-linear: brightening the shadows a lot and the highlights a little, like turning the whispers up without the shouts blowing out. Look at the drawing to see where the same objects land before and after:

Linear (freshly stacked) background, nebula and core: all here, in black Star Stretched (non-linear) Background Faint nebula Core Star
The same objects with the same data: stretching brightens the shadows a lot and the highlights a little, and everything finds its place.

And why green?

Color cameras have two green pixels for every red and blue one (the Bayer matrix), and light pollution tends to lean green too. When the program brightens the image automatically, that surplus green gets exaggerated. It goes away when you calibrate the color, a few steps further on.

R G G B A group of 4 pixels 1 red, 2 green and 1 blue The whole sensor half the pixels are green
With twice as many green pixels, the green channel collects more signal; if you don’t calibrate the color, the photo leans green.

Seeing it without touching it: the screen stretch

Almost every program has a display-only stretch. In Siril it’s at the bottom right: a dropdown that says “Linear” (the image as it is, black) which you can change to “AutoStretch” (the image brightened so you can see it). In PixInsight it’s called the STF. Take a look at these real screenshots:

A Siril screenshot with the stacked image of the Wizard Nebula almost black; an arrow points at the display dropdown, which reads “Lineal” (Linear).

1. “Lineal” (Linear) mode: the image as it is, unstretched. That’s why it looks black

The same Siril screenshot with the display dropdown on “AutoExtender” (AutoStretch): the Wizard Nebula appears green and red among thousands of stars; an arrow points at the dropdown.

2. “AutoExtender” (AutoStretch) mode: only the display changes. The image is still unstretched

Siril screenshots by Fran López, of the same stacked image. Click to see them larger. The screenshots, callouts included, show Siril in Spanish: where they read “Lineal” and “AutoExtender”, the English version reads Linear and AutoStretch.
  • With “AutoStretch” you can see it clearly, but the image is still unstretched: all that changed is how it’s displayed.
  • If you save it like that and open it in another program, it comes out black again. You’ve lost nothing: the AutoStretch isn’t saved.
  • From here the whole job is still ahead: removing the gradient, the color, the real stretch and the final touches, each with its own tool. They’re in the steps that follow.