Skip to content
ES App (ES) ↗
Step 3 of 4: The fans

Cooling your telescope down · Step 3 of 4

Fans: the one change you can actually see

In a sentence: A fan behind the mirror speeds the cooling up by 70%. A fan blowing across the face of the mirror triples it. Both were measured.

Two ways to fit one, and they’re not worth the same

The difference between the two setups is enormous and hardly anyone mentions it: the usual thing is to put the fan behind the mirror, which is the convenient spot and the one that does least. The one that really changes the night moves air in front, breaking up the layer stuck to the glass.

What Adler measured on his 8-inch Newtonian
SetupHow much fasterFrom 10 °C to 1 °C of difference
No fan—about 3 h 50 min
Fan behind the mirror, pulling air through the tube×1.7about 2 h 15 min
Fan blowing across the face of the mirror×3.0an hour and a quarter

The factors (×1.7 and ×3.0) are the ones Adler measured. The times are our own calculation with his formula, for a mirror 34 mm thick.

What really rules: the thickness

In Adler’s formula the cooling rate is inversely proportional to the thickness of the glass. A 16 mm mirror cools twice as fast as a 34 mm one of the same diameter.

That’s why aperture is a poor guide: one 200 mm telescope can take twice as long as another. If you know your mirror’s thickness, use it; if not, the calculator at the end assumes a typical thickness for your aperture and tells you it’s an estimate.

A Schmidt-Cassegrain is a different animal

An SCT doesn’t just have a mirror: it has a glass corrector plate closing the tube, and the air inside is sealed in. There is one measured run with five sensors on an 11-inch Celestron, starting from a 15.5 °C (28 °F) shock: the mirror was still about half a degree Celsius (1 °F) warm three hours in, and from there it tracked the air inside the tube for the rest of the night.

That same run shows something else interesting: the corrector plate went below air temperature, which is exactly the mechanism behind dew, and a low-power heater was enough to lift it just far enough.

Measure your own, if you like

Adler published the procedure so anyone can measure their own rate: take the difference between mirror and air, wait a while, measure it again and apply the formula. Give it time: in ten minutes the difference only changes by 10%, less than the error of a cheap thermometer, so it’s worth leaving half an hour or more between the two readings.